This work was conducted by three economists, not epidemiologists: Jonas Herby, Lars Jonung, and Steve H. "Throughout the pandemic, most COVID research out of Johns Hopkins University has typically come from its Coronavirus Resource Center, an initiative run out the university's world-renowned medical school.īut the new paper, which was drafted by three economists, comes out of the university's unaffiliated Krieger School of Arts and Sciences." Who Wrote This Paper? Rather it comes from the Krieger School of Arts and Sciences, a branch of JHU unaffiliated with the Coronavirus Resource Center: While many media outlets presented this working paper as if it was a "Johns Hopkins study," this report would be more accurately described as a non-peer-reviewed working paper by three economists, one of whom is an economics professor at Johns Hopkins University.įurthermore, the National Post noted that this paper did not come from Johns Hopkins University's Coronavirus Resource Center. This study was not endorsed by Johns Hopkins University. ![]() This opening paragraph contains one other important detail. The authors state as much in a brief description at the top of the study: A working paper typically refers to a pre-publication study that has not yet undergone a scientific peer-review process. The first thing we noticed when we examined the actual study, not the media reports covering the study, was that this was a "working paper" by a group of economists, not epidemiologists. ![]() Who is it from? What are the specific claims? What evidence are those claims based on? A Working Paper, Not Peer-Reviewed Published Study As this study appeared to run counter to previous reports that found lockdowns saved lives, we wanted to take a closer look at it. ![]() The paper claimed that the lockdowns implemented during the COVID-19 pandemic had little impact on preventing deaths. In February 2022, a number of conservative news outlets reported on a working paper entitled "A Literature Review and Meta Analysis of the Effects of Lockdowns on COVID-19 Mortality" by a group of scholars at Johns Hopkins University.
0 Comments
Leave a Reply. |